What's Lost When Parents Don't Talk About Social Identity With Their Kids? | MindShift

The answer’s complicated.

The vast majority of parents surveyed say they do feel comfortable talking about social identity. They just don’t do it.

That doesn’t surprise Beverly Daniel Tatum, a psychologist and author of the classic, Why Are All The Black Kids Sitting Together In The Cafeteria. “My guess is, some parents — certain majority parents — might think, ‘What’s to talk about?’ You know? Maybe there’s this sense of, it doesn’t really need to be talked about.”

With so many communities still deeply segregated, parents often look around and see only families that share their social categories. Even when parents do talk about identity, according to the survey, they often wait until their kids are 10, 11 or even 12 years old. Jennifer Kotler Clarke, who oversaw the Sesame survey, says parents seem to think younger kids don’t notice these differences, though “there’s all sorts of research that suggest that children very early on notice definitely physical differences between different people and they make meaning of those differences. And there’s discrimination very early on.”

How early on? Try six months old.

In a previous Life Kit episode on how to raise kind kids, we reported that, even as babies, humans not only show a preference for those who look and act like us, but they also show a desire to see those not like us be treated badly.

In a University of Toronto study, infants as young as six months old showed a preference for members of their own race and against members of different races. And this us vs. them mentality extends beyond physical differences.

[Professor Kiley] Hamlin, at the University of British Columbia, introduced a new variable to her puppet shows. When the puppet and baby liked different snacks, the baby wasn’t just less kind. She often wanted the puppet that did not share her snack preference punished.

“Babies did seem to care more about who was like them than they cared about niceness and meanness,” says Hamlin.

As a result, Kotler Clarke says, grown-ups need to be proactive about explaining the differences kids see and making clear: Different isn’t bad. If children don’t get help from parents “and have to try to make meaning of different social identities [on their own], they may come up with all sorts of weird and strange reasons that people are somewhat different.”

Exhibit A: Beverly Daniel Tatum still remembers the day her 3-year-old son was told by a white preschool classmate: ” ‘Your skin is brown because you drink chocolate milk.’ ” And then, she says, her son came home and asked if it was true. No, she assured him, your skin is brown because of something called melanin. We all have it, she told him — you simply have a little more.

This interaction highlights what may be the single biggest warning sign in Sesame’s new survey results: Many of the parents who are talking about race/ethnicity, gender, class and religion are doing so because their children are hearing negative comments about their own identities. Beverly Daniel Tatum explained the truth to her son about his skin color. But what about the little boy whose misconception set off this chain reaction?

According to Sesame’s survey results, 40% of black parents say their children have heard a negative comment about their race, and they are twice as likely as white parents to talk about race with their kids. Among parents of trans or nonbinary children, half reported their children hearing negative comments and were much more likely to talk about gender identity with their kids than were the parents of kids who’d heard no criticism.

“It’s not the role or responsibility of a group of parents to be having those conversations,” says Sesame’s Haider. “It really is the responsibility of everyone.”

In a separate survey, Sesame Workshop also queried preschool and elementary school educators about how they approach social identity in the classroom. Interestingly, teachers say they feel that social class — not race/ethnicity, gender, country of origin or any other social category — has the biggest impact on their students’ ability to succeed, yet class is also the category they believe is least appropriate to discuss in school, and the one they’re the least comfortable talking about with students.

MindShift