Maya Energy disputes the use of the term “dump” to describe the facility, and claims that the project will create as many as 124 full time jobs. In a statement to NPR, Maya Energy also writes: “The Maya Facility will recycle about 90% of the incoming waste and will divert the waste from it going to landfill, resulting in a positive environmental impact: reduction in greenhouse gas!”
But school administrators, teachers and other students were not convinced by Maya Energy’s statements. In interviews the boys conducted, many people were worried about noise and air quality. The company says it won’t burn anything at the facility, but hundreds of trucks a day could be needed to bring all the waste in to the facility.
“It’s exhibit A for environmental injustice,” says Kim Ferraro, senior staff attorney at the Hoosier Environmental Council, a non-profit environmental group in Indiana which has opposed the facility. “You have well-resourced industries that have political connections and the ability to run roughshod over existing communities that don’t have the resources to fight back.” ( More than a third of residents live below the poverty line in Gary.)
Initially all of the student activism seemed to have an impact. In October of last year, citing the concerns of Steel City Academy students, the Gary City Council voted 8-0 to reverse their earlier zoning approval for the Maya Energy project. Steel City Academy students were elated. One student activist, Danielle Sipp, told the Steel City Podcast, “People say young people can’t accomplish but yeah we can do these things if we put our minds together and act as a unit.”
But Maya sued the council in February and Gary City Council reversed back, clearing the way for Maya to build the plant. In March, the state’s Department of Environmental Management awarded Maya its solid waste permit.
Still, podcaster Erin Addison told NPR’s Audie Cornish the experience hasn’t diminished his pride in his city. “I’ve seen Gary for all of what it is. With the good and bad you take it all together and you’d get so much more good than you get bad. And I just love Gary, honestly.”
The boys all say the reporting has also increased their pride in themselves and shown them how much power they have. “I was always told to stay in a child’s place,” Evan says. “But now I know there are times where you have to tell people that they’re wrong.”
“We are definitely going to keep on the story,” adds Erin Addison. Evan and Andrew agree: The reporting will continue.
Producer Bill Healy leads the podcasting club at Steel City Academy and helped produce this story.